CVL-Caledon Literary Group Transcript for 2020-03-12

The Twilight Zone — The Obsolete Man

16:46 Phrynne hello Val!
16:47 Valibrarian Gregg hi!! just a sec- getting headset
16:47 Phrynne I should probably do that.
16:49 Phrynne ok, back with headset, more or less
16:50 Valibrarian Gregg I will send out a few reminders now
16:50 Phrynne no, not using the headset; too much to organize. I'm on a new comuter, Val.
16:55 PSP V1.2 Personal Space Protector off
16:56 Avatar Language HUD AvatarLanguage Version 1.1 initialized
16:56 WSJ-Trans BarBar2Banter Version 1.2.5
16:56 WhosOnSim HUD V2.0.0 (Oxbridge) WhosOnSim HUD V2.0.0
16:56 Bench_Pillow. Change your position with the fwd, back, shift+left, shift+right, PgUp, & PgDn keys
16:57 Bench_Pillow. Change your position with the fwd, back, shift+left, shift+right, PgUp, & PgDn keys
17:01 Valibrarian Gregg Several people just told me they are busy working on VWBPE projects!!
17:02 Valibrarian Gregg Welcome Andrea
17:02 Valibrarian Gregg We will be starting soon
17:02 Valibrarian Gregg Wordsmith- is this the best URL for us to view? https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6ywhne
17:03 Valibrarian Gregg I was thinking you might tell us exactly when to start so we can watch and chat at the same time!
17:03 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) oo already started
17:03 Valibrarian Gregg Oh that is okay!
17:03 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) remembers this one
17:03 Valibrarian Gregg It is a good one for sure!
17:04 Valibrarian Gregg We can discuss and chat right here in the local chat!
17:05 Valibrarian Gregg Here is the url to the episode https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6ywhne
17:06 Wordsmith Jarvinen Can everyone hear val and myself, or do we need to type stuff for you to get started?
17:06 Phrynne I could, and then it vanished. I will keep working at it
17:07 Sabre (sabreman.carter) y
17:07 Jenaea y
17:07 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) I can hear it
17:07 Valibrarian Gregg We will type here- during the video. So feel free to make comments!
17:10 Wordsmith Jarvinen Logic is an enemy and truth is a menace.
17:11 Valibrarian Gregg He is a librarian :)
17:11 Wordsmith Jarvinen mandatory period of one year and 11 months. conflicts with the ending.
17:12 Valibrarian Gregg "having to do with books"- but there are no more books!
17:12 Phrynne it's very 1950s in design-- minimalism in the set and costumes
17:13 Wordsmith Jarvinen Now even a society that rejects poetry, fiction, philosophy would still need technical books and manuals.
17:13 Valibrarian Gregg true- seems stark and dismal
17:13 Valibrarian Gregg good point Wordsmith
17:14 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) but not in a library exactly for public consumption, could be handed down trades ty;e
17:14 Valibrarian Gregg "my thought lives"!!
17:14 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) master to pupil
17:14 Wordsmith Jarvinen Words Mr. Wordsworth ..... a play on .... words.
17:14 Valibrarian Gregg all of those books, says the state "are but opiates"
17:15 Phrynne removal of nonconforming thoughts
17:15 Jenaea this could be a "new employee orientation" film at libraries everywhere...maybe not
17:15 Ololo Petya (olopierpa) hallo peeps
17:16 Valibrarian Gregg welcome ololo
17:16 Wordsmith Jarvinen Hi, Ololo.
17:16 Valibrarian Gregg We are discussing this video https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6ywhne The Obsolete Man
17:16 Ololo Petya (olopierpa) ty
17:17 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) ooo the right idea
17:17 Valibrarian Gregg "televised executions are educational"
17:17 Phrynne if they are going to broadcast from his room -- does that mean universal surveillance with recording capability?
17:17 Valibrarian Gregg like CCTV cameras everywhere? (they are aren't they)
17:18 Wordsmith Jarvinen He says in a bit that "they just installed the cameras this afternoon".
17:18 Valibrarian Gregg but at least we have teeny bit of privacy left
17:18 Wordsmith Jarvinen And look at all the books in his room.
17:19 Valibrarian Gregg /me loves that messy bookshelf!
17:19 Phrynne "I don't fit your formulae"
17:20 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) having a bible is crime punishable by death
17:20 Phrynne that reminds me of the Terror in France in the 1790s, with the public executions by guillotine
17:21 Wordsmith Jarvinen Similar
17:21 Valibrarian Gregg individual creative thought allowed.....think what we tell you
17:21 Valibrarian Gregg NOT allowed! I mean
17:21 Wordsmith Jarvinen Last year in the mass executions ... 1300 people in less than 6 hours.
17:22 Phrynne very Nazi
17:22 Valibrarian Gregg censorship gone mad!
17:22 Valibrarian Gregg no reading of other perspectives
17:22 Wordsmith Jarvinen Again, Logic is an enemy and truth is a menace.
17:23 Valibrarian Gregg a scary phrase Wordsmith- especially in what many call our moment in time "the post-truth era"
17:24 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) ands he is on global or national tv reading bible verses
17:24 Valibrarian Gregg a hidden bible
17:24 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) one among many i am sure
17:25 Wordsmith Jarvinen When one is going to die within a few minutes, an additional threat of death has no meaning.
17:26 Phrynne he has nothing to lose.
17:26 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) and his underling gets a promotion.
17:27 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) chum in the water
17:28 Wordsmith Jarvinen This broadcasting of an execution isn't quite going to plan.
17:28 Valibrarian Gregg two perspectives on death- observed LIVE
17:28 Valibrarian Gregg reminds me of our current obsession with LIVE events- live-streaming, twitter....
17:31 Wordsmith Jarvinen Now, what happened to the mandatory year and 11 months?
17:31 Phrynne only four women in that crowd.
17:31 Valibrarian Gregg nice choreography ;)
17:31 Valibrarian Gregg mob mentality
17:32 Sabre (sabreman.carter) he got his just desserts
17:32 Valibrarian Gregg yes! he did
17:32 Wordsmith Jarvinen Mob mentality -- removal of those who are inconvenient.
17:32 Valibrarian Gregg powerful message
17:33 Valibrarian Gregg Great episode with some thoughts for us all
17:33 Valibrarian Gregg the theme of valuing ALL people's ideas
17:33 Valibrarian Gregg and, of course, books hehe
17:33 Valibrarian Gregg got em on my head!
17:33 Wordsmith Jarvinen And librarians. ;)
17:34 Jenaea Wouldn't it be interesting if were large corporations instead of the state that found people obsolete, and instead of killing them they simply discarded them
17:34 Phrynne I wonder if any of his books were rescued by the people they sent to clear out his room -- to cause trouble later.
17:34 Valibrarian Gregg and what they represent- diverse perspectives, stories, history
17:34 Valibrarian Gregg good point Jenaea
17:35 Valibrarian Gregg Reminded me a bit of Fahrenheit 451
17:36 Valibrarian Gregg If we lose our history- there is a great cost
17:36 Wordsmith Jarvinen It certainly could be changed to involve corporations ruling instead of a "normal" state
17:36 Phrynne History -- they might not have wanted to hear of a different way of doing things.
17:36 Valibrarian Gregg or big data maybe? companies who have information about us that we do not even realize? lack of privacy
17:36 Wordsmith Jarvinen I think that was the depiction in the movie Rollerball.
17:36 Sabre (sabreman.carter) sorry I have tolog out
17:37 Valibrarian Gregg good to see you Sabre
17:37 Wordsmith Jarvinen tc Sabre, and thanks for coming.
17:37 Sabre (sabreman.carter) thank you for the program and the invite
17:37 Valibrarian Gregg and...fiction is important, too! We learn much from the perspectives of characters in literature
17:38 Valibrarian Gregg We can "live vicariously" and experience things that we would not otherwise...in the shoes of characters
17:38 Wordsmith Jarvinen How they perhaps think, feel, and are motivated or demotivated.
17:39 Valibrarian Gregg and historical fiction brings it "to life" more than just a list of facts....such as life during the depression or WWII etc
17:39 Wordsmith Jarvinen Think back to when we read "Fire watch"
17:39 Valibrarian Gregg but- if we only "think" what the state allows....we become shallow- or even zombie-like...right?
17:40 Phrynne if we do not have words to express ideas, can we think them?
17:40 Valibrarian Gregg LOVE that question Phyrnne! great psychologist Lev Vygotsky said "thought is born through words"....yet sometimes we think and cannot truly express it
17:41 Valibrarian Gregg He also had the analogy of thought being a sky filled with clouds....and words being the drops of rain coming down
17:41 Wordsmith Jarvinen I like that.
17:42 Valibrarian Gregg Since we never fully express every complete thought
17:42 Valibrarian Gregg but when we read....the thoughts of another human enter our own- that is pretty amazing! right?
17:43 Valibrarian Gregg We sorta take it for granted and don't think about it
17:43 Wordsmith Jarvinen I ran across this article on words for emotions that have no direct English translation: https://getpocket.com/explore/item/the-untranslatable-emotions-you-never-knew-you-had?utm_source=pocket-newtab
17:43 Valibrarian Gregg Another cool thing -- when we read a book, we each are reading a different book! because we bring our whole life to the connotation of each word.
17:44 Valibrarian Gregg new words! great Wordsmith
17:45 Wordsmith Jarvinen And there's the Welsh word hiraeth, which has its closest match in Portuguese Saudade
17:46 Wordsmith Jarvinen https://sites.psu.edu/kielarpassionblog2/2016/04/02/hiraeth/
17:46 Valibrarian Gregg me thinks you are living up to your name hehe
17:46 Wordsmith Jarvinen A bit. ;)
17:47 Phrynne The authorities in that show probably didn't like poetry because it can not only express but interpret reality -- it can be code for other ideas, not just talking about concrete things but thought.
17:47 Valibrarian Gregg hhmm interesting Phynne
17:47 Valibrarian Gregg just the facts, mam!
17:48 Wordsmith Jarvinen Poetry has layers of meaning, as do songs of rebellion and resistance.
17:48 Valibrarian Gregg sometimes deep meaning can be expressed in metaphor...better than in fact- don't you think?
17:49 Phrynne Definitely.
17:49 Wordsmith Jarvinen Often a way to convey at least part of a meaning.
17:49 Valibrarian Gregg perhaps we should read a poem sometime for our literary study? :)
17:49 Phrynne Or many meanings.
17:50 Valibrarian Gregg Or several - if short
17:50 Phrynne "a night sky" could speak of astronomy, weather, emotions, ...
17:50 Valibrarian Gregg might be fun
17:50 Phrynne sounds good
17:50 Wordsmith Jarvinen We can look for such
17:50 Valibrarian Gregg You can decide Wordsmith! if you run across something
17:51 Valibrarian Gregg but I know people do enjoy the sci-fi and it always leads to good discussions
17:51 Phrynne There used to be some members of the Science Fiction Writers Association who were poets, but I am not remembering the names well right now.
17:51 Valibrarian Gregg Wordsmith- you got my email about the VWBPE panel- where you can talk a bit about this group collaboration?
17:52 Andrea Jones (andreajonesms) gotta go. keeba needs me. bye all. great discussion
17:52 Valibrarian Gregg yes- I am sure there are some great sci-fi poems out there
17:52 Valibrarian Gregg bye Andrea :) nice to see you
17:52 Wordsmith Jarvinen I couldn't resist today's. A central character who is a librarian, and the value of people not in lockstep agreement.
17:52 Wordsmith Jarvinen Thanks for coming, Andrea. :)
17:52 Wordsmith Jarvinen Great to see you here.
17:53 Wordsmith Jarvinen I can search, and consult with someone who has a basement full of sci-fi books. :P
17:53 Valibrarian Gregg That would be great
17:54 Valibrarian Gregg Our next study is THURS April 9 at CVL
17:54 Valibrarian Gregg so- you can email or IM me :)
17:54 Wordsmith Jarvinen Will do.
17:54 Valibrarian Gregg great!
17:55 Valibrarian Gregg This was fun....a nice change of pace to chat and watch
17:55 Wordsmith Jarvinen Until VWBPE.
17:56 Valibrarian Gregg yes! Hope to see you all there!
17:56 Valibrarian Gregg VWBPE is always amazing :)
17:56 Wordsmith Jarvinen We've got an Oxbridge exhibit there, and I'm on the early access list.
17:57 Valibrarian Gregg oh I will come check it out!
17:57 Valibrarian Gregg Do any of you go to Kitely?
17:57 Wordsmith Jarvinen That phrase about logic and truth, couldn't be more timely.
17:57 Valibrarian Gregg We have an immersive tour this Sunday! in Kitely
17:57 Valibrarian Gregg YES- logic and truth :)
17:57 Phrynne What time, Val?
17:57 Valibrarian Gregg 1pm SLT
17:58 Phrynne nods
17:58 Valibrarian Gregg https://www.vwbpe.org/conference/program
17:58 Valibrarian Gregg It is the first event on the program! a kick-off in Kitely!
17:58 Valibrarian Gregg maybe I will see you there :)
17:58 Wordsmith Jarvinen I might install a viewer and give it a try.
17:58 Valibrarian Gregg CVL has several spaces in Kitely- but SL is still our main branch
17:58 Valibrarian Gregg that would be great!
17:59 Phrynne Oh, Kitely is a different grid?
17:59 Wordsmith Jarvinen Yes
17:59 Valibrarian Gregg yes- I use Firestorm to get to Kitely
17:59 Phrynne my FS recent download is SL only -- it doesn't allow other places yet
17:59 Valibrarian Gregg You can sign up for an avatar at Kitely.com
17:59 Phrynne I can look into it
17:59 Valibrarian Gregg or you can use the Singularity viewer too
17:59 Wordsmith Jarvinen I believe there's a separate version.
18:00 Phrynne that's possible.
18:00 Valibrarian Gregg yes- I hear there is a version that supports Kitely
18:00 Valibrarian Gregg I use that one
18:00 Valibrarian Gregg well this was really fun!
18:00 Valibrarian Gregg and I look forward to next time
18:00 Valibrarian Gregg Have a good night all
18:00 Wordsmith Jarvinen Always fun.
18:00 Ololo Petya (olopierpa) nini all
18:01 Valibrarian Gregg bye for now
18:01 Wordsmith Jarvinen tc Val. Til again.
18:01 Phrynne bye!